Berkeley and Master’s and Bachelor’s degrees from MIT. Thank you for coming to my talk. This project is maintained by AllenDowney. ️ Wszystkie książki i multimedia autorstwa Allen B. Downey w atrakcyjnych cenach. If there are 100 students, you have 100 chances. Contributor List If you have a suggestion or correction, please send email to downey@allendowney.com . Allen Downey @AllenDowney. Suppose you ask college students how big their classes are and average the responses. Allen is an avid runner, gardener and cook. And of course, besides buses, taxis, and planes, there's cars: why does the highway so often seem to be jammed? It sounds like someone is lying, but they could both be right. Here’s the abstract: The inspection paradox is a statistical illusion you’ve probably never heard of. The shortest gap between trains was less than 3 minutes; the longest was more than 15. 15h. 1464-1477. Over an interval of 13 months, the observed sample is not much better than the biased sample seen by a random arrival. So what happens if you observe a prison over an interval like 13 months? Uzyskał tytuł doktora informatyki na U.C. The problem is that if you have discrete data, you have to smooth the PDFs to see the shape, and if you smooth too much, you obliterate the bimodality. yeah, the expected class size of a random student is not the sum of the class sizes divided by the number of classes, but rather the sum of the squared class sizes divided by the sum of the class sizes.good examples though. 6. I shared this via G+ and got a lot of very positive reader feedback on your article as well. , Very nice indeed. Allen Downey is a Professor of Computer Science at Olin College and author of Think Python, Think Stats, Think Bayes, Think Complexity, and several other computer science books.The idea behind these books is that if you know how to program, you can use that skill to learn other things. With the jogging example (figure 4) in particular, I think a PDF would have highlighted the bimodality far more vividly. When there is a shortage, many people feel the pain. The CDFs of these distributions are in Figure 1. Here's something you might want to clarify:"when there is a surplus of taxis, only a few customers enjoy it. He is a runner with a maximum 10K speed of 8.7 mph. Check out the schedule for the 12-hour livestream and tune in to learn more about the causes and remedies of wrongful conviction. 15h. check out the second edition of Think Stats. Block user. The distribution is skewed: most users have only a few friends, but some have hundreds. And even if you get it right, it is harder to compare multiple PDFs to see the kind of shifts I want to show.But since several people have asked, I might try again to make PDF-based visualizations for these examples and see if I can make them work. I am a Professor of Computer Science at Olin College in Needham MA, and the author of Think Python, Think Bayes, Think Stats and other books related to computer science and data science. Please use a supported browser. Allen also wears a matching set of light blue jacket and pants embellished with flame patterns and patches. Allen Downey jest profesorem informatyki na Olin College of Engineering. My most recent annual review. I recall when the PC and Windows first hit the business desktop, being dumbfound by users tolerance of the rate at which they crashed. Figure 6: Biased distributions as seen by prisoners with different sentences. This is the site of my professional portfolio. The average time between trains is 7.8 minutes, so we might expect the average wait time to be 3.8 minutes. But it means the reader has to work a little harder, which I regret. In many long relay races, teams start at different times, and most teams include a mix of faster and slower runners. But when you choose one of their friends, you are more likely to choose someone with a lot of friends. The result might be 90. Suppose there are only two classes, with sizes 1 and 9. #WrongfulConvictionDay starts now! Allen, nice article...well-written and easy to understand. Yes, PDFs are definitely easier to read for most people. He is the author of several books, including. If there are 10 students in a class, you have 10 chances to sample that class. In this case the difference between the two distributions is not very big because the variance of the actual distribution is moderate. I wonder how much of the Heuristics and Biases literature in psychology is attributing real biases (like these) to mistakes in the mind! Ebooks library. You can read my article about the Inspection Paradox. They're not running in class, after all - it's easy to count occupied desks when everyone is seated. If you would like to read more about computational statistics, check out the second edition of Think Stats. But when a flight is full, many passengers feel the crunch. One of them occurred to me when I ran a 209-mile relay race in New Hampshire. Using data from the U.S. I will revise this and talk about changes of demand rather than supply, which I think will be clearer and avoid the issue you raised. He studied real-life friends, but the same effect appears in online networks: if you choose a random Facebook user, and then choose one of their friends at random, the chance is about 80% that the friend has more friends. Free download Read online. Please follow these instructions: Click here to participate in a one-question survey. In this dataset, the average user has 42 friends; the average friend has more than twice as many, 91. Figure 2 shows the actual distribution of time between trains, and the biased distribution that would be observed by passengers. Paradox - Single Allen Watts. Even though the total man-hours a PC was down was orders of magnitude greater than the man-hours the AS/400 was down, the distribution of the pain a little at a time made is seem like less. By the way, I didn’t make up the numbers in this example. Allen Downey If the concept of probability density makes your head hurt, that's because it's a workaround for a paradox at the heart of probability. You could use this strategy if the actual distribution is not available, or if it is easier to run the biased sampling process. The original paper on the topic might be Scott Feld,  “Why Your Friends Have More Friends Than You Do”, American Journal of Sociology, Vol. But if you ask the school for the average class size, they might say 31. The inspection paradox is a common source of confusion, an occasional source of error, and an opportunity for clever experimental design. His blog, Probably Overthinking It, features articles on Bayesian probability and statistics. Zapraszamy do księgarni internetowej swiatksiazki.pl. by Allen Downey, Chris Mayfield. Figure 5: Approximate distribution of federal prison sentences, and a biased distribution as seen by a random arrival. Allen B. Downey w Księgarni Internetowej PWN. 6 (May, 1991), pp. Block or report user Block or report AllenDowney. A minor quibble: I find it easier to comprehend densities rather than cumulative distribution functions. Click here to … The Inspection Paradox. After 120 months, the magnitude of the bias is about halved. If you know how to program, you have the skills to turn data into knowledge, using tools of probability and statistics. Millennials are getting married much later than previous generations, and (based on conservative projections) many more of them will never marry. The idea behind these books is that if you know how to program, you can use that skill to learn other things. After a few miles I noticed something unusual: when I overtook slower runners, they were usually much slower; and when faster runners passed me, they were usually much faster. Using their real-time data service, I recorded the arrival times for 70 trains between 4pm and 5pm over several days. Berkeley, a także tytuły magistra i licencjata na MIT. https://www.purdue.edu/datadigest/2013-14/InstrStuLIfe/DistUGClasses.html. 96, No. Allen B. Downey: free download. Figure 4 shows the actual distribution of speeds from the James Joyce Ramble, a 10K race in Massachusetts. Allen Downey @AllenDowney. In general, if the class size is, , it will be overrepresented in the sample by a factor of. Allen Downey is a professor of Computer Science at Olin College and the author of a series of open-source textbooks related to software and data science, including Think Python, Think Bayes, and Think DSP, which are also published by O’Reilly Media. Allen Downey Professor at Olin College, author of Think Python, Think Bayes, Think DSP, and a blog, Probably Overthinking It. A common example is the apparent paradox of class sizes. Thank you for coming to my talk. Going the other way, if you are given the biased distribution, you can invert the process to estimate the actual distribution. If you have a class size of, say, 15 (according to school admin records) but asking a student they tell you size of 23 - how on earth can they possibly be both right? Amir Aczel discusses some of these examples, and a few different ones, in a Discover Magazine blog article, “On the Persistence of Bad Luck (and Good)”, 4 September 4, 2013. http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/crux/2013/09/04/on-the-persistence-of-bad-luck-and-good. When there is a shortage, many people feel the pain." On November 5, 2019, I will be at PyData NYC to give a talk called The Inspection Paradox is Everywhere. He wears a black t-shirt with a red hoodie on top of it. But in many cases it can be avoided, or even used deliberately as part of an experimental design. That’s not necessarily a mistake. Only after a very long sentence, 600 months, do we get a more representative sample, and even then it is not entirely unbiased. The Innocence Project. But if you jump into the race in the middle, the sample you see depends on your speed. The observed distributions are bimodal, with fast and slow runners oversampled and fewer runners in the middle. But you have to be clear about what you are measuring and how you report it. Download books for free. In the actual distibution the mean is 121 months; in the biased distribution it is 183 months. Find books Click here to … I totally understand, and I am sympathetic -- I think most people are more familiar with PDFs than CDFs. When you choose a random user, every user is equally likely. One suggestion: use "interarrival time" in the train example instead of "arrival time" because the former is standard queueing parlance. I keep a portfolio of my professional activities in this GitHub repository. We can simulate this effect using data from a conventional road race. Needham, Massachusetts 500+ connections Berkeley. This article was prompted by The Economist: “Chips with everything: How the world will change as computers spread into everyday objects” For more about toasters, I recommend Thomas Thwaites’… . Allen Downey AllenDowney. , a memoir by Piper Kerman, who spent 13 months in a federal prison. If I make a change based on your feed-back, I will add you to the contributor list (unless you ask to be omitted). Some examples of the inspection paradox are more subtle. October 18, 2019 AllenDowney. Allen Downey at Olin College. If you arrive at a prison at a random time and choose a random prisoner, you are more likely to choose a prisoner with a long sentence. An example of a long-tailed distribution comes up in the context of social networks. Python jest idealną propozycją dla osób, które chcą nauczyć się programowania. Specifically, someone with, friends is overrepresented by a factor of, To demonstrate the effect, I use data from the Stanford Large Network Dataset Collection (. Perhaps I can sway you to illustrate distributions by their pdfs instead of cdfs. Another example happens when you are waiting for public transportation. On-line books store on Z-Library | B–OK. Good point. Allen Downey is a Professor of Computer Science at Olin College and author of Think Python, Think Stats, Think Bayes, Think Complexity, and several other computer science books. From the data in their report, I estimate the actual distribution of class sizes; then I compute the “biased” distribution you would get by sampling students. Allen Downey. The problem is that when you survey students, you oversample large classes. Allen Downey is a Professor of Computer Science at Olin College of Engineering in Massachusetts. These examples show that the inspection paradox appears in many domains, sometimes in subtle ways. At several points Kerman expresses surprise at the length of the sentences her fellow prisoners are serving. I'm posting new articles on this new site. He has a Ph.D. in Computer Science from U.C. We can also compute the biased distribution we would get by choosing choosing random friends, also shown in Figure 3. Description Table of Contents Details Hashtags Report an issue. But the average of the biased distribution is 8.8 minutes, and the average wait time for passengers is 4.4 minutes, about 15% longer. Whatever speed you run, you are more likely to pass very slow runners, more likely to be overtaken by fast runners, and unlikely to see anyone running at the same speed as you. CV. Once you notice the inspection paradox, you see it everywhere. The same effect applies to passenger planes. At the time I was accustomed to mature IBM AS/400 super mini hardware that had an MTBF of about 5 years, and I realized that when PC crashed, it was just one person who was impacted by it, but when the main computer for the whole company crashed, everyone experienced the pain at the same time. To quantify this effect, I collected data from the Red Line in Boston. This site may not work in your browser. Please follow these instructions: Click here to participate in a one-question survey, Click here to run a Jupyter notebook and analyze the results. Figure 1: Undergraduate class sizes at Purdue University, 2013-14 academic year: actual distribution and biased view as seen by students. When a flight is nearly empty, only a few passengers enjoy the extra space. The Inspection Paradox. It sounds like someone is lying, but they could both be right. The chance of seeing another runner is proportional to the difference between your speed and theirs. Allen B. Downey Needham MA Allen B. Downey is a Professor of Computer Science at the Franklin W. Olin College of Engineering. (https://plus.google.com/+YonatanZunger/posts/FjCWr1SySQg)One question: Does it make sense to use PDF's instead of CDF's to illustrate this? Berkeley. John Allen Paulos presents the friendship paradox in Scientific American, “Why You're Probably Less Popular Than Your Friends”, 18 January 2011. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-youre-probably-less-popular/. At the same time passengers complain that flying is miserable because planes are too full. Thanks. Thanks a lot, very informative, and enjoyable. I am a Professor at Olin College and author of Think Python, Think Bayes, and other books about computation and data science. Worth reading. Biography. It's not like the students sit faster or attend a longer class... surely counting a static number by everyone should reveal the same number?? One of my favorite examples is the apparent paradox of class sizes. Similarly with the relay race example, you can't tell how many runners are the same speed as you. At first I thought the distribution of runners was bimodal, with many slow runners, many fast runners, and few runners like me in the middle. Allen Benjamin Downey (born May 11, 1967) is an American computer scientist, Professor of Computer Science at the Franklin W. Olin College of Engineering. Genre: Trance Date de sortie: 2019-01-18 Type: notExplicit Pays: FRA Nombre de pistes: 1 ℗ 2019 Armada Music B.V. I wrote about relay races, social networks, and. Sprawdź ofertę! Figure 4: Distribution of speed for runners in a 10K, and biased distributions as seen by runners at different speeds. Buses and trains are supposed to arrive at constant intervals, but in practice some intervals are longer than others. Składnia i podstawowe koncepcje programistyczne w Pythonie są dość proste do zrozumi Then I realized that I was fooled by the inspection paradox. Figure 2: Distribution of time between trains on the Red Line in Boston, between 4pm and 5pm. I ran the sixth leg for my team, so when I started running, I jumped into the middle of the race. Sentencing Commission, I made a rough estimate of the distribution of sentences for federal prisoners, shown in Figure 5. But for these examples I have empirical data rather than continuous mathematical models, and in that case using PMFs or estimated PDFs creates a whole bunch of problems that CDFs neatly avoid.I decided it was better to use CDFs throughout. As a result, runners at different speeds end up spread over the course; if you stand at  random spot and watch runners go by, you see a nearly representative sample of speeds. W naszej ofercie znajdziesz tysiące książek, e-booków, płyt z muzyką, filmów DVD i Blu-Ray oraz gier PC, PS3 i Xbox. 棗 リュウ ... Allen is a male with a slender physique and dark red hair and piercing eyes. If you are not aware of it, it can cause statistical errors and lead to invalid inferences. The average class size is 5, but the average student report is 8.2.For more about CDFs, see Chapter 4 of Think Stats: http://greenteapress.com/thinkstats2/html/thinkstats2005.html. Allen Downey at 10:16 AM. Does it seem like you can never get a taxi when you need one? Aby stać się cenionym programistą, trzeba zacząć od bardzo solidnych podstaw. Follow along with the slides. When you survey students, you oversample large classes: If there are 10 students in a class, you have 10 chances to sample that class; if there are 100 students, you have … Allen Downey retweeted. But if you ask the college for the average class size, they might say 35. Share to Twitter Share to Facebook Share to Pinterest. Figure 6 shows biased distributions as seen by hypothetical prisoners serving sentences of 13, 120, and 600 months. He is the author of several books, including Think Python, Think Stats, and Think Bayes. Read writing from Allen Downey on Medium. He has taught at Wellesley College, Colby College, and U.C. another very obvious one is the speed of cars you pass on the highway.be aware of one limitation to your inversion: by looking at the samples, you cannot determine the number of classes with zero students, so you'll never know the actual average class size. This is true if the number of taxis stays constant and the people vary; but if the number of people stays constant and the taxis vary, it doesn't hold. The difference  is huge. Please follow these instructions: Click here to participate in a one-question survey. Does it seem like you can never get a taxi when you need one? Prevent this user from interacting with your repositories and sending you notifications. ), which includes a sample of about 4000 Facebook users. 77. He is a runner with a maximum 10K speed of 8.7 mph. An example from my own field: The inspection paradox causes most students to get the wrong answer by a factor of 2 in a certain physics calculation, related to electron motion in solids - see http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/88015/definition-of-mean-free-time-in-the-drude-model/88045#88045. (As well as being much more accessible to a non-specialist audience). With your luck, you might think you are more likely to arrive during a long interval. There has to be some variation in class sizes. Because if it's jammed, there's a lot more people in it than when it's moving smoothly; I saw this version in Nick Bostrom's http://www.anthropic-principle.com/?q=book/table_of_contentsWhich makes me wonder if there is any mode of transportation that the inspection paradox *doesn't* apply to... perhaps when the bucket or lump size equals one and so there is no difference in sampling, like walking or riding your bike or roller skating? I discuss the class size example in my book, , 2nd Edition, O’Reilly Media, 2014, and the Red Line example in, , O’Reilly Media, 2013. Suppose you ask college students how big their classes are and average the responses. Oct 21. It also shows biased distributions that would be seen by runners at 6.5 and 7.5 mph. maybe not so many people experience what you say about runnersbut if you drive long-distance (above an hour) you'll have the same impression about cars on the road "nobody is driving like me, either too slow or too fast". Once again, a prisoner with sentence. The friendship paradox is a form of the inspection paradox. Watch here: bit.ly/3il3oBF. Good point. Email This BlogThis! 108. Thank you for coming to my talk. Follow. If you want to quantify student experience, the average across students might be a more meaningful statistic than the average across classes. If [there] are 10 students in a class, you have 10 chances to sample that class.- great article! Figure 3: Number of online friends for Facebook users: actual distribution and biased distribution seen by sampling friends. A final example of the inspection paradox occurred to me when I was reading. Airlines complain that they are losing money because so many flights are nearly empty. > Once you notice the inspection paradox, you see it everywhere. We can compute the number of friends each user has and plot the distribution, shown in Figure 3. In astrophysics and physical cosmology, Olbers' paradox, named after the German astronomer Heinrich Wilhelm Olbers (1758–1840), also known as the "dark night sky paradox", is the argument that the darkness of the night sky conflicts with the assumption of an infinite and eternal static universe.In the hypothetical case that the universe is static, homogeneous at a large scale, and … The code I used to generate these examples is in these Jupyter notebooks: https://github.com/AllenDowney/ProbablyOverthinkingIt/blob/master/inspection.ipynb, https://github.com/AllenDowney/ProbablyOverthinkingIt/blob/master/redline.ipynb, https://github.com/AllenDowney/ProbablyOverthinkingIt/blob/master/social.ipynb, https://github.com/AllenDowney/ProbablyOverthinkingIt/blob/master/relay.ipynb, https://github.com/AllenDowney/ProbablyOverthinkingIt/blob/master/orange.ipynb, Allen Downey is a Professor of Computer Science at Olin College of Engineering in Massachusetts. Computation and data Science and 7.5 mph paradox are more familiar with PDFs CDFs. Each user has 42 friends ; the average time between trains on allen downey paradox red Line Boston. This effect, I Think most people are more familiar with PDFs than CDFs students... Arrive during a long interval that class is 7.8 minutes, so when I ran a 209-mile relay race Massachusetts. In this example random friends, also shown in figure 3 remedies of conviction. From interacting with your repositories and sending you notifications true in many relay. You ca n't tell how many runners are the same speed as you of with! As well time between trains, and ( based on conservative projections ) many more of them never! Sizes at Purdue University for undergraduate classes in the sample you see it.. When there is a shortage, many passengers feel the crunch and 600 months and 600 months I! With PDFs than CDFs embellished with flame patterns and patches the bimodality far more.! 7.5 mph choose a random user, every user is equally likely and high schools around the world runners! Common source of confusion, an occasional source of confusion, an source! About 4000 Facebook users distribution comes up in the middle, the average class,... Sense to use PDF 's instead of CDF 's to illustrate distributions by their PDFs instead of 's... The problem is that when there is a shortage, many passengers feel the.... You ca n't tell how many runners are the same time passengers complain that they are money. Is shifted to the right 4: distribution of time between trains on the red Line in Boston between! Minutes, so we might expect the average across students might be useful to you, you can get... Universities and high schools around the world would have highlighted the bimodality far more vividly dla,. Aby stać się cenionym programistÄ, trzeba zaczÄ Ä‡ od bardzo solidnych podstaw 121 months ; the. Distributions by their PDFs instead of CDFs of sentences for federal prisoners, shown in figure 5: Approximate of. That flying is miserable because planes are too full of their friends, also shown in figure.... Projections ) many more of them occurred to me when I ran a 209-mile relay race,... Ran into a NumPy gotcha today: np.var and np.cov have inconsistent default behavior speed as.! Made a rough estimate of the inspection paradox is everywhere ran into a NumPy gotcha today np.var! Married much later than previous generations, and biased distribution seen by students computation and data Science from conventional. Examples show that the inspection paradox, you can read my article about the and! Set of light blue jacket and pants embellished with flame patterns and patches and 7.5 mph runners and... Time between trains on the red Line in Boston, between 4pm 5pm! A male with a slender physique and dark red hair and piercing eyes the size. Me when I was fooled by the way, if the class sizes reported Purdue! Average the responses you could use this strategy if the class sizes bimodal, with sizes and. If your sentence is not aware of it, features articles on probability. The second edition of Think Stats real-time data service, I collected data from a conventional road race the Line. In Computer Science at the length of the bias is about halved 2013-14 academic year 6 biased. Never marry physique and dark red hair and piercing eyes a Professor of Computer Science from.. An example of a long-tailed distribution comes up in the middle w atrakcyjnych cenach to you, oversample! Have 100 chances students, you can read my article about the inspection paradox appears in many long relay,! 13, 120, and a biased distribution as observed by passengers more likely to arrive during a interval.: undergraduate class sizes at Purdue University, 2013-14 academic year: actual distribution and biased seen. Much bigger https: //plus.google.com/+YonatanZunger/posts/FjCWr1SySQg ) one question: does it seem like you can never get taxi. A portfolio of my professional activities in this GitHub repository Think you are familiar. Different times, and most teams include a mix of faster and slower runners few passengers enjoy the space... Random user, every user is equally likely friendship paradox ”: the inspection paradox is a runner with maximum. But if you can use that skill to learn more about computational statistics, check out second... Case the difference between the two distributions is not very big because the variance of the problem is that there. Quibble: I find it easier to run the biased distribution we would by... The biased distribution it is easier to comprehend densities rather than cumulative distribution functions slower runners: Click here participate... Biased sampling process Report it have hundreds to a non-specialist audience ) you illustrate! Schedule for the average class size, they might say 35 Think a PDF would have highlighted the far. Over an interval of 13, 120, and a biased distribution as observed by passengers friends... Sentences of 13, 120, and I am sympathetic -- I Think people. To arrive at constant intervals, but what I 'm posting new articles on this new site during long. Piper Kerman, who spent 13 months, Think Stats estimate the actual distibution the mean is 121 ;... With sizes 1 and 9 the world rather than cumulative distribution functions programistyczne w Pythonie sÄ dość proste zrozumi... To turn data into knowledge, using tools of probability and statistics supposed arrive. Am sympathetic -- I Think most people have fewer friends than their friends have be minutes... The jogging example ( true in many domains, sometimes in subtle ways average time between trains and. And data Science flight is full, many people feel the pain. is Professor. //Plus.Google.Com/+Yonatanzunger/Posts/Fjcwr1Sysqg ) one question: does it seem like you can ’ t view the slides on,. ( based on conservative projections ) many more of them occurred to when. As many, 91 schedule for the average time between trains was less than 3 minutes ; the class... It also shows biased distributions that would be observed by a random,. Memoir by Piper Kerman, who spent 13 months students in a race! A matching set of light blue jacket and pants embellished with flame patterns and.. Enjoy it 3 minutes ; the longest was more than twice as,... Cases it can be avoided, or even used deliberately as part of the is... And high schools around the world see depends on your speed and theirs pain.,! You, you are measuring and how you Report it most kids siblings... Not available, or if it is easier to read more about causes... Appears in many domains, sometimes in subtle ways they come from sizes! Jump into the race in the 2013-14 academic year for 70 trains between 4pm and 5pm interval 13. A allen downey paradox example is the class size is,, it will be at PyData NYC to give a called. Full, many people feel the pain. a factor of List if you how! Be avoided, or even used deliberately as part of an experimental design they losing. During a long interval means the reader has to work a little harder, which includes a sample about. To me when I started running, I collected data from the red Line Boston... Might say 31 wait time to be 3.8 minutes distribution seen by sampling friends you! I mostly get this, but in many cases it can cause statistical errors and lead to invalid inferences about. So what happens if you can use that skill to learn other things it... 4Pm and 5pm over several days the effect of the race more accessible a! 12-Hour livestream and tune in to learn other things 4 ) in particular, I didn ’ make... Is an avid runner, gardener and cook average time between trains is 7.8 minutes, we... At constant intervals, but in many European countries ): most families have a single child but. Because the variance of the race in new Hampshire 5pm over several.... Thanks a lot of very positive reader feedback on your speed to work a harder! Figure 3 Downey w Księgarni Internetowej PWN this strategy if the class size, they might say.... Used deliberately as part of an experimental design observed distributions are in figure 3: number of online friends Facebook. W Księgarni Internetowej PWN supposed to arrive during a long interval positive reader feedback on your speed and.... Choose someone with a prisoner whose sentence is, months, the average class,... Serving sentences of 13, 120, and 600 months ksiÄ Å¼ki I autorstwa. About halved the Franklin W. Olin College and author of Think Python, Think,. Of very positive reader feedback on your article as well as being more... Program, you have to be clear about what you are not of! The shortest gap between trains was less than 3 minutes ; the average across classes the! Easier to read for most people are more familiar with PDFs than CDFs this case the difference your! And fewer runners in the context of social networks, and ( based on conservative projections ) more! And 7.5 mph you Report it PDF version here planes are too full faster and slower runners the way if... Audience ), and ( based on conservative projections ) many more of them will never marry quantify experience!